Is there actually anyone gay in Plymstock on this site?
Plymstock is a suburb of around 35,000 people, which means a realistic gay dating pool once you include the broader south Plymouth catchment from Plympton to Oreston.
This is the first question and the fair one. A local site is only useful if it has local members, and it would be dishonest to promise you a queue of men waiting two streets away. What we can say honestly is this: Plymstock sits within Plymouth, a city of around 260,000 people. The gay population is proportionally what you would expect from a city that size, and because this site covers the whole city rather than splitting it across a forty-mile radius, members in Plymstock, Hooe and Elburton are genuinely in the same pool as members in Stonehouse and St Jude's.
The catch with any local site is density. Plymouth is not Brighton. But it is also not a village, and the south side of the city is a significant population centre in its own right. The realistic expectation is that you will see fewer profiles than on a national app, but that every profile you do see is someone who could reasonably meet you for a drink at the Morley Arms in Plymstock or a walk around Radford Lake, the nature reserve tucked between Plymstock and Oreston that makes for an unhurried first meeting without any pressure.
Tip: the members most likely to respond quickly are those who log in regularly. Use the activity filter to find people who have been online recently rather than scrolling through dormant profiles from two years ago.
What makes dating on Plymouth's south side different?
Plymstock and the surrounding area have a quieter, more residential feel than the city centre, which shapes both what people want from dating and where it is easy to meet.
The south side is not Barbican or Union Street. There is no obvious gay venue here in the way there might be in the city centre, which means meeting up tends to be more relaxed and more ordinary. A walk, a pub, a coffee. That is not a disadvantage. It is actually what a lot of people prefer, especially if you have been burned by apps where every match seems to exist only in a specific kind of venue on a specific kind of night.
Plymouth also has something worth naming plainly: a large naval and Royal Marines population. Devonport Dockyard and HMNB Devonport are a significant part of how this city works. That affects dating across the whole city, and it affects it for gay men too. Deployments are ordinary here. Long gaps in availability are ordinary. If you are messaging someone and they disappear for six weeks, the most likely explanation is a sea deployment, not a loss of interest. The site treats this as a normal scheduling fact, not a problem to apologise for.